The #1 factor that determines if an item will sell on Etsy: demand
Published on
The number one factor that determines if an item will sell on Etsy is demand—selling something that people actually want. No matter how well-crafted or unique your item is, if there isn’t a market for it, it won’t sell. Understanding what customers are searching for, what trends are popular, and where there is unmet demand are key to succeeding on Etsy.
Why demand matters
Etsy is full of amazing products, but not all of them will sell. You could have the most creative item, but if people aren’t looking for it, it won’t go anywhere. The first rule of selling on Etsy is to understand what people want and make sure your product matches that.
Here’s what you need to do to figure out demand:
1. Find your niche
Etsy is known for handmade and unique items, but the trick is finding a niche—a smaller, specific market where people are passionate about certain products. Instead of trying to sell to everyone, focus on a particular group of people who are really interested in your kind of product.
For example, instead of selling general home decor, focus on something more specific, like boho wall art or custom pet portraits. By doing this, you’ll have a better chance of finding buyers who are ready to purchase.
In Listadum, enter the keyword that best represents your item and check out the quadrant chart to get a sense of the demand. Something in the green zone means that there is a demand and not yet too much competition, these are usually great niches!
2. Follow trends
Etsy buyers love trendy items, so staying up-to-date with what’s popular is a smart move. Sellers who catch onto trends early can stay ahead of the competition.
Check out Etsy’s Trending Now section or look at social media like Pinterest and Instagram to spot what’s popular right now. These can give you ideas for products that have high demand.
3. Use the right keywords
Etsy’s search bar is how buyers find your products, so using the right keywords is really important. Keywords are the words people type in when they’re searching for something to buy. If your product listings don’t match what people are searching for, they won’t find you.
Listadum's Keyword Explorer integrated into the listing manager is here to help you find popular keywords people are using. This helps you understand what’s in demand and what words to use in your listings to get more views. For each keyword, you will find hundreds of similar, connected, or related keywords that could help you reach more potential buyers.
4. Listen to what customers are saying
A great way to know what buyers want is by paying attention to reviews and feedback—not just in your own shop, but in others too. Check out what people are saying about similar products. Are there any features they wish existed? Are there things they love?
For example, if lots of buyers mention they want personalized options, that’s a sign you could offer something customized to fill that demand. The more you listen to your buyers, the better you can meet their needs.
5. Test your products
Before going all-in on one product, it’s smart to test out a few different versions. Etsy makes it easy to list similar items with small differences, like color or design. Watch how they perform and see which one gets the most attention.
Once you know what’s working, focus on the products that are selling the best. This helps you make smart decisions and sell more items that people actually want.
Conclusion: Demand is the key to your success on Etsy
To be successful on Etsy, it’s not just about being creative or having a great shop. The most important thing is making sure there’s demand for what you’re selling. By researching what people want, staying on top of trends, and listening to customer feedback, you can create products that sell and grow your Etsy business.
This version is simpler and more accessible while still covering the key points. Does this work better for you?